Under the National Employment Standards (NES) in the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), employees are entitled to paid personal leave if they are unfit for work and paid carer’s leave to care for a sick family member.
But what about complex situations?
Here’s what the NES says:
1. Can an employee use paid personal/carer’s leave for elective medical treatment?
The Commission says, yes. In Australian Workers’ Union v Cement Australia (2025), Commissioner Hunt of the Fair Work Commission (FWC) observed:
- The NES entitles employees to paid personal/carer’s leave for elective cosmetic surgery.
- This is no different than their entitlement to paid personal/carer’s leave if they have, for example, a burst appendix.
- If medical certificates are produced declaring the employee to be too ill to attend work, they are entitled to be absent from the workplace and paid for it.
- This applies even if they are ill as a result of elective treatment.
2. Can an employee take NES personal/carer’s leave to attend a medical appointment?
The Commission says, no. The Fair Work Commission (FWC) Full Bench has clarified:
- Employees are not entitled to paid personal/carer’s leave solely to attend a medical appointment.
- Personal leave under the NES applies only when an employee is unfit for work due to illness or injury.
- The model clause for family and domestic violence leave confirms that employees may take unpaid leave to attend medical appointments when necessary.
3. Can an employee take NES personal/carer’s leave to bring a family or household member to a medical appointment?
The Commission says, yes.
In Wilkie v National Storage Operations Pty Ltd (2013), the Fair Work Commission (FWC) ruled:
- Employees are entitled to paid carer’s leave if a family or household member is ill, injured, or facing an unexpected emergency and requires their care or support, including being taken to a medical appointment.
- This entitlement may also apply when the family member’s condition results from elective cosmetic surgery, as noted by Commissioner Hunt.
- Employers cannot take adverse action against employees for exercising their right to personal/carer’s leave.
- In this case, the FWC found that an employer’s decision to demote an employee for using carer’s leave to care for an unwell child amounted to unlawful adverse action.
4. Can an employee take NES personal/carer’s leave without providing a medical certificate?
The Commission says, it depends.
In Curious Grace v O’Brien (2019), the Fair Work Commission (FWC) ruled:
- Employers can require evidence that would satisfy a reasonable person that the leave is taken for a valid reason under the NES.
- It is generally reasonable to request a medical certificate or statutory declaration for extended or frequent absences.
- Falsifying a medical certificate may be grounds for dismissal, but dismissal is not always justified. In this case, the FWC found that an employee who falsified a medical certificate faced unfair treatment, as the employer’s requirement for documentation did not align with company policy.
- The FWC ruled that while the employee’s actions warranted disciplinary action, dismissal was too harsh given the circumstances, including previous workplace victimization.
💡 Key Takeaway
Employees have rights, but clear policies and reasonable evidence requirements are crucial to ensuring compliance in the workplace.
Stay Connected!
Have any questions or need more details?
Reach out to us. We’d love to hear from you!
Ross
Legal Practice Director, Drayton’s Law