Are You Set Up to Set Off?

Workers in high-vis vests walking through a warehouse

In FWO v Woolworths Group Limited; FWO v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 1092, Justice Perram delivered a significant ruling that employers relying on annualised salary arrangements cannot use excess payments from one pay period to cover award shortfalls in another. Woolworths and Coles had both structured their contracts so that annualised salaries would satisfy all award obligations (including overtime, penalty rates and allowances) calculated and pooled over a 26-week period. The Court rejected this approach, finding that section 323(1) of the Fair Work Act requires award entitlements to be discharged by actual payments within the same pay period. In plain terms: each pay cycle must stand on its own.

The decision also carries a serious record-keeping sting. The Court found that record-keeping obligations under the Fair Work Regulations apply to salaried employees just as they do to hourly workers. Employers must separately document overtime hours, penalty rates, loadings and allowances even where those entitlements are nominally absorbed into a salary. Woolworths’ clock-in/clock-out system, combined with rosters, was held insufficient. Where records are missing or incomplete, the burden of proof reverses under section 557C of the FW Act. This means that the employer must disprove underpayment allegations, not the other way around.

For employers, the practical implications are immediate. Any set-off clause that pools or averages obligations across multiple pay periods, or uses language like “satisfied over six months”, is now at legal risk. Contracts should be reviewed to ensure set-off clauses clearly identify which award obligations are being discharged and align to the actual pay cycle. Conducting a pay period-by-period compliance review and strengthening record-keeping systems now is recommended.

See our earlier article on the Coles and Woolworths decision.

For advice on how this applies to your business, contact the Drayton’s team.

Free download

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Thanks. Your download is ready.

Download the PDF
Something went wrong. Please call us on (07) 3831 7099 and we will send it to you.
Talk to us about this